Can the Decoherent Histories Description of Reality be Considered Satisfactory?
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this letter, we discuss some features of the Decoherent Histories approach; more specifically, we put forward four assumptions, the first three of which, according to us, are necessary for a sound interpretation of the theory, while the fourth one is accepted by the supporters of the DH approach. We then prove that such assumptions lead to a logical contradiction and thus cannot hold simultaneously. In the last section, we discuss the consequences of relaxing any one of them: our conclusion is that the theory is either incomplete or it does not yield a realistic description of physical world.
منابع مشابه
ua nt - p h / 99 12 06 5 v 1 1 3 D ec 1 99 9 About the Notion of Truth in the Decoherent Histories Approach : a Reply to Griffiths
Griffiths claims that the “single family rule”, a basic postulate of the decoherent histories approach, rules out our requirement that any decoherent history has a unique truth value, independently from the decoherent family to which it may belong. Here we analyze the reasons which make our requirement indispensable and we discuss the consequences of rejecting it. This short letter is a reply t...
متن کاملDecoherent histories quantum mechanics with one real fine-grained history
Decoherent histories quantum theory is reformulated with the assumption that there is one “real” fine-grained history, specified in a preferred complete set of sum-over-histories variables. This real history is described by embedding it in an ensemble of comparable imagined fine-grained histories, not unlike the familiar ensemble of statistical mechanics. These histories are assigned extended p...
متن کاملar X iv : 1 10 6 . 07 67 v 3 [ qu an t - ph ] 2 8 N ov 2 01 1 Decoherent Histories Quantum Mechanics with One “ Real ” Fine - Grained History
Decoherent histories quantum theory is reformulated with the assumption that there is one “real” fine-grained history, specified in a preferred complete set of sum-over-histories variables. This real history is described by embedding it in an ensemble of comparable imagined fine-grained histories, not unlike the familiar ensemble of statistical mechanics. These histories are assigned extended p...
متن کاملProbability in decoherent histories
The decoherent (consistent) histories formalism has been proposed as a means of eliminating measurements as a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics. In this formalism, probabilities can be assigned to any description which satisfies a particular consistency condition. The formalism, however, admits incompatible descriptions which cannot be combined, unlike classical physics. This seems to le...
متن کامل1 v 1 7 D ec 1 99 9 Decoherent Histories and Realism
In this paper we reconsider the Decoherent Histories approach to Quantum Mechanics and we analyze some problems related to its interpretation which, according to us, have not been adequately clarified by its proponents. We put forward some assumptions which, in our opinion, are necessary for a realistic interpretation of the probabilities that the formalism attaches to decoherent histories. We ...
متن کامل